The toxic swamps surrounding cancer cells

Drawing of a tumor in swamp

The many different types of cancer are difficult to treat for a wide variety of reasons. They have different causes, evolve rapidly, and hide in different parts of the body. Despite their variety, all cancer cells are dangerous because they grow uncontrollably and multiply quickly. In the process, they can form tumors, sap up nutrients from their surroundings, and produce wastes that can kill other cells. They form veritable swamps of dangerous cellular waste and death that make them difficult to treat. These toxic cancer swamps can signal bad news for the cancer sufferer and can protect cancer cells from the immune system.

Drawing of a tumor within a swamp
A tumor surrounded by the toxic swamp of its own creation.

Getting trapped in the cancer swamp

Immune cells have ways of recognizing and killing cancer cells before they cause too many problems. However, immune cells have difficulty penetrating cancer swamps. Much like Atreyu’s horse in “The Neverending Story,” these cells get stuck in the swamps and cannot complete their quest. They fail to protect your body.

Indeed, even if they do manage to slog through the swamps, immune cells might not survive there long enough to kill cancer. In the swamps, immune cells have few nutrients to energize them and some of the substances produced by cancer cells directly harm them. Finally cancer cells can even produce molecules that specifically shut off immune cells.

More than creating toxic swamps, cancer cells can evolve to further remodel their local environments (their microenvironments in biologist jargon). For instance, tumor cells sometimes evolve the ability to attract blood vessels which deliver more nutrients to the tumor. Cancer cells can use these blood vessels to travel to new sites in the body, establish satellite swamps, and cause further harm.

Cleaning up the cancer swamp

Luckily, researchers are well aware of the swamps and other hazards surrounding cancer cells. They’ve already modified immune cells to make them better at fighting cancer and these “immunotherapies” have successfully treated certain blood cell cancers. To make immunotherapies more effective at fighting other types of cancer, researchers are actively looking for ways to clear out (dear I say “drain”) cancer swamps. We may not be stuck in the cancer swamp for long!

When an Effective Cancer Treatment Makes Your Cells Riot: Cytokine Release Syndrome

Researchers and doctors have found many effective ways to modify cancer patients’ own immune cells and use them to attack cancer cells. They have been so successful that one type of these so-called “immunotherapies” was even considered the “Advance of the Year” in 2018 by the American Society of Clinical Oncology. However, these therapies are not perfect. Some immunotherapies cause overactivation of the immune system, which can result in terrible side effects including damage to internal organs. Cumulatively, this overactivation and its side effects are known as cytokine release syndrome. Thankfully researchers are coming up with inventive ways to limit or stop cytokine release syndrome, which makes immunotherapies even more powerful.

Researchers don’t yet fully understand all the specific activities that cause the dangerous overactivation of the immune system during immunotherapy. You can think of this overactivation as something like a riot or stampede of cells. When doctors give cancer patients modified immune cells, they do a fantastic job of killing cancer cells, but they also sound the alarm and throw out a bunch of signals saying “SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE DONE!” These signals activate other immune cells, those immune cells send out more signals, and then even non-immune cells can begin acting irregularly.

Drawing a modified immune cell attacking a cancer cell and causing a riot
A cellular riot caused by a modified immune cell used to attack a cancer cell

This cellular rioting can lead to disruption of blood vessels, flu-like symptoms, and damage to organs; but, luckily, doctors know how to treat many of these things. Doctors can give patients drugs that will limit the negative side effects of the cellular riot and block some of the alarms. Nonetheless, these drugs aren’t equally effective in all patients, and there is no one-size-fits-all treatment that can be used in every case.

Recognizing this issue, researchers are working to make it so the modified cells used in immunotherapy don’t cause cellular riots. These researchers are further modifying the immune cells so that they send out fewer alarm signals in the first place and can be destroyed if a riot begins.

Importantly, even without these new modifications, immunotherapies are already very effective at treating cancers of the blood (read the Advance of the Year article for more). I’m hopeful that researchers will be able to make immunotherapies more effective against other types of cancers soon (think solid tumors), and the ability to control these cellular riots will be the icing on the immunotherapy cake. It’s an exciting and hopeful time for cancer researchers and patients!

References:

  1. Chakravarti, Deboki, and Wilson W. Wong. “Synthetic biology in cell-based cancer immunotherapy.” Trends in biotechnology33.8 (2015): 449-461. PubMed PMID: 26088008. PubMed Central PMCID: PMC4509852.
  2. Shimabukuro-Vornhagen, Alexander, et al. “Cytokine release syndrome.” Journal for immunotherapy of cancer 6.1 (2018): 56. PubMed PMID: 29907163. PubMed Central PMCID: PMC6003181.

3 Effective Cancer Immunotherapies

You’ve probably heard that a lot of money goes into cancer research but haven’t heard enough about its impacts. Through a series of coincidences at work, I found myself reading quite a bit about cancer immunotherapy – using the human immune system to better fight cancer. I was astonished by how many effective cancer therapeutics are coming out of this field and thought I’d quickly describe how a few of them work here.

*A Couple of Quick Notes* – We need new cancer therapeutics because standard cancer treatments (things like surgery to remove tumors, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy) can damage our bodies in terrible ways and are often ineffective. Also, even though the therapies below have been successful in some cases, every cancer is different, and they won’t be successful for all types of cancers or even all patients with a particular type of cancer.

3 Types of Successful Immunotherapy

1. Adoptive Cell Therapy

Cartoon of a cell used in cell therapyThere are many different types of cells in the immune system. These play a variety of roles in fighting disease causing agents (pathogens) like viruses, bacteria, and cancer cells (yes, our bodies naturally fight cancer). In adoptive cell therapies, scientists take immune cells out of our bodies, make the cells better at fighting cancer, propagate them, and then put them back into our bodies.

Before the immune system can begin fighting a pathogen effectively, the cells that do the fighting need to be told a pathogen is present and what it looks like. Dendritic cells do this by showing components of the pathogen to other cells in the immune system. In one form of adoptive cell therapy, doctors take dendritic cells from a patient, load them with cancer cell components, and put them back in the patient’s body where they can alert the rest of the immune system to the presence of the cancer.

For more information, read up on Sipuleucel-T, an FDA approved adoptive cell therapy for prostate cancer.

2. Antibody Therapy

Cartoon of antibody therapyYou may have heard of antibodies. These are proteins that our immune systems naturally produce. Antibodies bind to pathogens and prevent them from causing disease. Through years of research, scientists have learned ways to produce antibodies that bind to cancer cells and slow cancer progression.

For example, some cancer cells produce a signal that tells the immune system to slow down and stop attacking them. Scientists have produced antibodies that bind to and block this signal. These antibodies have been proven effective at boosting the immune system and fighting a wide variety of cancer types.

For more information, read up on PDL1 inhibitors and watch this great video from Dana Farber.

3. CAR-T Cells

Cartoon of a CAR-T cell getting ready to attack a cancer cell.CAR T-cell therapy combines aspects of adoptive cell and antibody therapy. T-cells normally bind to and kill cancer cells, but can only do so if they have the appropriate binding proteins. In CAR T-cell therapy, doctors take T-cells from a patient and give them new proteins called chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) that are very similar to antibodies. CARs allow the T-cells to bind to cancer cells. Once put back into the patient, these CAR T-cells can be effective at binding to and fighting the cancer.

CAR T-cells are effective at fighting a few types of cancer and have completely cured some patients who were otherwise out of hope.

Read Up on CAR T-Cell Therapy.